Newsletter of Phenomenology

Keeping phenomenologists informed since May 2002

Repository | Book | Chapter


(2015) Objectivity in science, Dordrecht, Springer.

A plurality of pluralisms

collaborative practice in archaeology

Alison Wylie

pp. 189-210

Innovative modes of collaboration between archaeologists and Indigenous communities are taking shape in a great many contexts, in the process transforming conventional research practice. While critics object that these partnerships cannot but compromise the objectivity of archaeological science, many of the archaeologists involved argue that their research is substantially enriched by them. I counter objections raised by internal critics and crystalized in philosophical terms by Boghossian, disentangling several different kinds of pluralism evident in these projects and offering an analysis of why they are epistemically productive when they succeed. My central thesis is that they illustrate the virtues of epistemic inclusion central to proceduralist accounts of objectivity, but I draw on the resources of feminist standpoint theory to motivate the extension of these social-cognitive norms beyond the confines of the scientific community.

Publication details

DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-14349-1_10

Full citation:

Wylie, A. (2015)., A plurality of pluralisms: collaborative practice in archaeology, in F. Padovani, A. Richardson & J. Y. Tsou (eds.), Objectivity in science, Dordrecht, Springer, pp. 189-210.

This document is unfortunately not available for download at the moment.