Repository | Journal | Volume | Articles
Warning: Illegal string offset 'id' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 338
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 338
Warning: Illegal string offset 'idparent' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 339
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 339
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publityp' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 340
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 340
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publititle' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 341
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 341
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publititlesub' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 342
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 342
Warning: sizeof(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/LoopData.php on line 595
Warning: Illegal string offset 'collname' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 345
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 345
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publivolume' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 346
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 346
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publinumber' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 347
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 347
Warning: Illegal string offset 'pagerange' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 348
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 348
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publiyear' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 349
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 349
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publisher' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 350
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 350
Warning: Illegal string offset 'publiplace' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 351
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 351
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parentplace' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 352
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 352
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parentpublisher' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 353
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 353
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parentitle' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 354
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 354
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parentauthor' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 355
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 355
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parenteditor' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 355
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 355
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parentcollname' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 356
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 356
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parentvolume' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 357
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 357
Warning: Illegal string offset 'parentnumber' in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 358
Notice: Uninitialized string offset: 0 in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/PubliFormat.php on line 358
Extended functionalism, radical enactivism, and the autopoietic theory of cognition
prospects for a full revolution in cognitive science
Mario Villalobos, David Silverman
pp. 719-739
Recently, Michael Wheeler (2017) has argued that despite its sometimes revolutionary rhetoric, the so called 4E (embodied-embedded-enacted-extended) cognitive movement, even in the guise of ‘radical’ enactivism (REC), cannot achieve a full revolution in cognitive science. A full revolution would require the rejection of two essential tenets of traditional cognitive science, namely internalism and representationalism. Whilst REC might secure antirepresentationalism, it cannot do the same, so Wheeler argues, with externalism. In this paper, expanding on Wheeler’s analysis (2017), we argue that what compromises REC’s externalism is the persistence of cognitively relevant asymmetries between its purported cognitive systems and the environment. Complementarily, we argue that an antirepresentationalist ancestor of enactivism, the autopoietic theory of cognition, is able to deliver and secure externalism, thus offering the explosive combination (i.e., antirepresentationalism plus externalism) that Wheeler claims us needed for a revolution in cognitive science.
Publication details
DOI: 10.1007/s11097-017-9542-y
Full citation:
Villalobos, M. , Silverman, D. (2018). Extended functionalism, radical enactivism, and the autopoietic theory of cognition: prospects for a full revolution in cognitive science. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 17 (4), pp. 719-739.
This document is unfortunately not available for download at the moment.