Repository | Journal | Volume | Articles

In a recent book (Tye 2017), Michael Tye argues that we have reason to attribute phenomenal consciousness to functionally similar robots like commander Data of Star Trek. He relies on a kind of inference to the best explanation – "Newton's Rule', as he calls it. I will argue that Tye's liberal view of consciousness attribution fails for two reasons. First, it leads into an inconsistency in consciousness attributions. Second, and even more importantly, it fails because ceteris is not paribus. The big, categorical difference in history between Data-like robots on the one hand and human beings on the other hand defeats the ceteris paribus assumption, which can be seen by various considerations. So the inference rule cannot be applied. We should not attribute phenomenal consciousness to robots like Data.

Warning: mysqli_connect(): (HY000/2002): Cannot assign requested address in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/UtilSite/GenDBconnect.php on line 24

Warning: mysqli_query() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 200

Warning: mysqli_connect(): (HY000/2002): Cannot assign requested address in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/UtilSite/GenDBconnect.php on line 24

Warning: mysqli_query() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 327

Warning: mysqli_close() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 329

Warning: sizeof(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/LoopData.php on line 595

DOI: 10.1007/s11097-017-9528-9

Warning: mysqli_connect(): (HY000/2002): Cannot assign requested address in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/UtilSite/GenDBconnect.php on line 24

Warning: mysqli_query() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 327

Warning: mysqli_close() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 329

Warning: sizeof(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/LoopData.php on line 595

Warning: count(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenFormat.php on line 173

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenFormat.php on line 175

Warning: mysqli_connect(): (HY000/2002): Cannot assign requested address in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/UtilSite/GenDBconnect.php on line 24

Warning: mysqli_query() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 327

Warning: mysqli_close() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 329

Warning: count(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenFormat.php on line 173

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenFormat.php on line 175

Warning: mysqli_connect(): (HY000/2002): Cannot assign requested address in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/UtilSite/GenDBconnect.php on line 24

Warning: mysqli_query() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 327

Warning: mysqli_close() expects parameter 1 to be mysqli, bool given in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/GenDButil.php on line 329

Warning: sizeof(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/LoopData.php on line 595

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/clients/b010bcc84441ff7c5adbaf4e922effaa/web/ocoph/Util/LoopData.php on line 832

Full citation: