Repository | Journal | Volume | Articles
(2019) Synthese 196 (1).
Agents necessitating effects in Newtonian time and space
from power and opportunity to effectivity
Jan Broersen
pp. 31-68
We extend stit logic by adding a spatial dimension. This enables us to distinguish between powers and opportunities of agents. Powers are agent-specific and do not depend on an agent's location. Opportunities do depend on locations, and are the same for every agent. The central idea is to define the real possibility to see to the truth of a condition in space and time as the combination of the power and the opportunity to do so. The focus on agent-relative powers and space-relative opportunities firmly roots effectivity of an autonomous choice making agent in a space–time picture. Our space–time view will be classically Newtonian, since we will assume relativistic phenomena do not play a role in agentive effectivity. We show how our semantics naturally distinguishes between different kinds of histories; histories that reflect real (factual) possibilities and histories that reflect counterfactual possibilities (of a particular hypothetical kind). Furthermore, we discuss how the spatial picture sheds light on conceptual problems plaguing the central stit property of "independence of agency'. At several points in the article we will emphasise and defend the differences with Belnap's theory of agency in relativistic branching space–times.
Publication details
DOI: 10.1007/s11229-018-1769-9
Full citation:
Broersen, J. (2019). Agents necessitating effects in Newtonian time and space: from power and opportunity to effectivity. Synthese 196 (1), pp. 31-68.
This document is unfortunately not available for download at the moment.